The Housing Market Needs More Cowbell
It’s hard to believe that the classic “More Cowbell” SNL skit aired 21 years ago this week. I played a lot of Blue Oyster Cult in high school and college but since I saw this 2000 skit live when it aired, I’m all in (on cowbells). To this day I have a cowbell from my son’s old drum kit on my workbench and I have a cowbell app on my iphone that plays Christopher Walken saying “I’ve gotta have more cowbell” when you touch the cowbell image. This is the type of technology we really need. Will Ferrell said later on when he bumped into Walken (who played Bruce Dickinson) said : ‘You know, you’ve ruined my life…People during curtain call bring cowbells and ring them. The other day, I went for Italian food lunch, and the waiter asked if I wanted more cowbell with my pasta bolognese.’
But I digress…
Heavy Manhattan Rental Market Leasing Activity Is Aiding In Price Stabilization
This week Douglas Elliman published our research on the Manhattan, Brooklyn and Queens  rental markets for March 2021. This is part of our expanding Elliman Report series I’ve been authoring for 26 (gulp) years. while the rental market is still seeing significant year over year price drops, they are slowly abating after peaking last fall. Net effective median rent (face rent including concessions) has not seen a month over month decline in four months. Of course rents tend to rise after the new year but the higher gain from February to March suggests that stability is coming.
I’m not sure if this has happened before but the reporting on two of our Douglas Elliman market reports became the 11th (Manhattan rents ) and 18th (Westchester sales ) of the day by the ±350K Bloomberg Terminal subscribers. A two-fer!
One of the interesting patterns that has evolved in Manhattan rentals is that marketing time has spiked, not because rentals are taking more time to rent (afterall, new lease signings for March had the highest March total since we began tracking in 2008) but rather that, older inventory is being cleared from the market and being rented. I would think this will be a short term data quirk as inventory continues to decline. Here are two versions of the same chart.
Here is our chart using our research data from the Elliman report that shows month over month changes in net effective median rent. Journalists are taught that 3 data points make a trend and here are four.
MANHATTAN RENTAL MARKET HIGHLIGHTS
“Net effective median rent has begun to show month to month stability in the new year.”
- The highest number of March new lease signings since tracking began in 2008
- Net effective median rent rose month over month for four straight months at highest rate in a decade
- The dollar amount of rental concessions rose to the third highest level since 2008
- Doorman new lease signings continued to rise by about twice the rate as non-doorman lease signings
- Existing new lease signings increased by more than twice the rate as new development lease signings
- Landlord concessions market share for the luxury market was nearly half that of the non-luxury market
- Lower price tranches continued to see a larger percentage decline in median rent than higher tranches
BROOKLYN RENTAL MARKET HIGHLIGHTS
“New lease signings have continued to rise sharply since the fall.”
- New leases rose sharply year over year for the seventh consecutive month
- The net effective median rent fell year over year for the ninth straight month
- Lower price tranches continued to see a larger percentage decline in median rent than higher tranches
QUEENS RENTAL MARKET HIGHLIGHTS
“Despite the steady decline in rental price trends, new lease signings have not trended higher.”
- Net effective median rent fell year over year for the eleventh straight month
- New lease signings fell year over year for the second time in three months
- The market share of landlord concessions has fallen by nearly half since peaking in November
The Manhattan Count Is Edged Out By Beijing Billionaires (But Our Air Is Cleaner)
The battle for high net worth individuals pivot from Manhattan to Beijing (by 1? Give me a break).
TLDR “The Answer Is No” – Are Californians to Blame for Salt Lake’s Rising Housing and Rental Rates?
It sounds to me like many in Utah are blaming California  on their high cost housing woes, yet this is happening everywhere. California was recently blamed for Idaho’s drop in housing affordability in this excellent piece . Record low mortgage rates and lack of new supply will do that. The proliferation of inbound and outbound migration narratives has been endless. This one by the non-profit think tank The Utah Foundations  blends data from Atlas and United Van Lines as well as the Tax Foundation, USPS and NAR.
At this point, the only thing I am sure of is that everyone needs to blame someone for something rather than solving the problem.
The New York Post  looked at another migration study by CBRE this week and I chimed in.
COVID Impacted Long Island Towns Differently: Some Boomed and Some Bammed
There was a recent Newsday piece: 6 boomtowns: What’s driving rising home prices in communities across LI  [subscription] that looked at the change in prices by town using data we compiled from the LI MLS and the results were quite different across the market.
On a macro level, this reminds us not to brushstroke housing markets as being consistent. This is not a new idea to ponder. If you have a subscription, it’s quite interesting to see the variance in performance. The variation in prices don’t infer individual property appreciation but these markets in aggregate are influenced by shift in product mix that sells and post-lockdown, that’s been in favor of higher end. By using median sales price, these numbers are not skewed by a few gigantic transactions.
No Zero-Sum Game Apparent: The Westchester Housing Market Continues to Rock (More Sales and Rising Prices)
Some anticipated that the recent rebound in Manhattan sales and early signs of rental price stabilization there would come at the expense of the suburban markets that surround NYC. Yet Westchester County showed us that the market remains very tight and robust, not a bastion of affordability. If we zoom out of NYC metro, the NYC suburbs are behaving just like the rest of the U.S. (rising prices and sales, falling inventory)
Prices are rising because the market is in need of more listing inventory. This is a national condition and I see this challenge as a crisis – affordable housing will be an economic challenge to the U.S. for decades. And you can thank record low mortgage rates for that. Low rates drive asset prices higher and this has been going on for decades now.
Bloomberg covered the report  and produced a scary chart (black and white versions).
New York City Investment Sales Don’t Seem To Be Rebounding Yet
The year end jump in NYC investment sales activity seemed to be more about tax avoidance planning for 2021 rather than a true uptick in demand. Deals in 4Q20 were down 14%  from the average of the three prior quarter.
Here’s what 2021 would like like after annualizing 1Q-21. Not pretty.
Palm Beach Continues To Defy Gravity With Another Mega Sale
Before we dive into the mega sale pool, new signed contract activity from our Florida research for the Douglas Elliman report shows growing interest in this region. Bloomberg’s chart and article  makes it quite obvious:
These mega sales are no longer an anomaly. As broken by the Wall Street Journal , Oracle founder Larry Ellison just paid $80 million for a home in Palm Beach and the fourth sale above $50 million in 2021. For those that are curious, these four sales ranged from $3,100 to $5700 per square foot on 1-3 acres (I don’t know Ellison acreage yet.)
And here’s my chart to illustrate the consistency of this phenomenon in recent years. I maintain that this is a new market subset that appears here to stay but has little bearing on housing for mere mortals.
(For earlier appraisal industry commentary, visit my old clunky REIC  site.)
Appraiser Waivers Shifted From An Exception To The Rule
For all the talk about how important appraisers are to risk management by the GSEs, we really aren’t. There is a compelling blog post using AEI data by Ryan Lundquist over at Sacramento Appraiser Blog .
Appraisal Buzz Interviews Dave Bunton, TAF President, on Buzzcast
Joan Trice’s podcast started out with a diversity question – asking Dave what TAF is doing about the lack of it in the profession. The lobbing of softballs was probably necessary to have Dave on the call. Dave is a very good bureaucrat and a nice guy who has a knack for saying things in a proactive sounding way. Yet Dave has been at the helm of this gatekeeper organization for more than three decades and until this year never had an African-American on the AQB. For those of you not familiar with the Appraiser Qualifications Board (AQB), they set technical policy which determines entry into the profession. Dave clearly acknowledges that the profession doesn’t reflect our U.S. population demographics (which he is essentially the gatekeeper). His answers sound like this issue is some sort of deep mysterious challenge. He went on to address the steps TAF is taking including the recent formation of diversity committee which, incredibly, is not headed by an African-American (nor are any members of the committee). This is how systemic racism evolves. This organization didn’t start taking action until outside critics began to point out the problem and public pressure influenced the need for action. But if the organization never dealt with diversity and didn’t practice it and either didn’t see it or pretend it wasn’t an issue, then how can they be tasked with fixing the problem? Good grief. Take the two year mentoring process for example – unlicensed appraisers trying to get their two years experience is virtually impossible.
To be honest with my listeners, I could only listen to the first ten minutes (halfway) and then I had to turn it off. Perhaps my listeners can let me know how it ends. Based on the lack of credible actions so far to fix the problem, the pressure is only going to get worse. Why not be proactive now? Wait, I know the answer: “It’s nearly impossible to fix a problem your actions showed you were oblivious of for three decades.”
OFT (One Final Thought)
As I’ve told my (adult) kids for years: Old people can rock.
Brilliant Idea #1
If you need something rock solid in your life (particularly on Friday afternoons) and someone forwarded this to you, or you think you already subscribed, sign up here for these weekly Housing Notes . And be sure to share with a friend or colleague if you enjoy them because:
- They’ll play more cowbell;
- You’ll play more cowbell too;
- And I’ll rock.
Brilliant Idea #2
You’re obviously full of insights and ideas as a reader of Housing Notes. I appreciate every email I receive and it helps me craft the next week’s Housing Note.
See you next week.
Reads, Listens and Visuals I Enjoyed
- Oracle’s Larry Ellison Buys Palm Beach Mansion for $80 Million [Wall Street Journal] 
- Significant Statistics | Are Californians to Blame for Salt Lake’s Rising Housing and Rental Rates? [Utah Foundation] 
- Biden seeks to ease housing shortage with $5 billion 'carrot, no stick' approach [Reuters] 
- Are Residential Conversions the Answer NYC Is Looking For? [Multi Housing News] 
- Market Insight: The State of Luxury Real Estate in Paris [Yahoo Finance] 
- NYC's Investment Sales Dropped Again To Start 2021 After Hints Of Recovery [Bisnow] 
- How 10 Famous NYC Buildings Got Their Names – Page 8 of 8 [Untapped New York] 
- Woolworth Building “Pinnacle” Penthouse Relists For $79M [The Real Deal] 
- Cities Set to Construct the Most Homes [MReport] 
- What If Compass Is Basically Just Like Every Other Real-Estate Brokerage? [Curbed] 
- No More Love Letters To Home Sellers, Calif. Realtors Advise [CBS Local Los Angeles] 
- Dueling proposals to convert commercial properties into housing [City and State New York] 
- New York State Is Set to Raise Taxes on Those Earning Over $1 Million [NY Times] 
- If You Sell a House These Days, the Buyer Might Be a Pension Fund [Wall Street Journal] 
- What Biden's infrastructure plan does for housing [HousingWire] 
My New Content, Research and Mentions
- At least 200,000 people fled New York City. Which neighborhoods have lost the most population to the pandemic? [Explica .co] 
- City's rental market showing signs of stabilizing year into pandemic [Crain's NY] 
- Manhattan renters scoop up lingering units in discount frenzy [Business Times] 
- Brooklyn Prices, Sales and Inventory Rise in Q1 [The Real Deal] 
- Westchester’s suburban homes are still the rage as city reopens [Crain's NY] 
- Brooklyn’s Median Home Price Surges 12% ito a Record $900,000 [Mansion Global] 
- Manhattan lease signings surged in March, but there are many empty apartments [Brick Underground] 
- Westchester’s Suburban Homes Are Still the Rage as NYC Reopens [Bloomberg] 
- 6 boomtowns: What's driving LI's rising home prices [Newsday] 
- Brooklyn Sees Surprising Gains in Real Estate Prices, Transactions and Inventory in 2021 [Brownstoner] 
- Westchester County Home Sales Stay Strong in Q1 2021 [The Real Deal] 
- New Leases Rise in Brooklyn and Manhattan March 2021 [The Real Deal] 
- Manhattan Renters Scoop Up Lingering Units in Discount Frenzy [Bloomberg] 
- Exodus citywide in NYC — but mostly from these zip codes [NY Post] 
- Busca por mansões de Palm Beach dispara em mudança estrutural [Yahoo Esportes] 
- Скок в цените на луксозните имения в Palm Beach [Bloomberg] 
- Palm Beach County Mansions Scooped Up In Hot Pandemic Market [Financial Advisor Magazine] 
- Palm Beach Mansions Are Flying Off the Market. Is a Bubble Forming? [Commercial Observer] 
- U.S. services sector posts record growth in March following eases in coronavirus restrictions [Washington Post] 
- Palm Beach County Mansions Scooped Up in Hot Pandemic Market [Bloomberg] 
- LA pending condo sales jump over 88% in March [Livabl] 
- Brooklyn has become so popular it now costs nearly as much to live there as it does in Manhattan [Business Insider] 
- Manhattan sales rise above pre-pandemic levels for the first time [Crain's New York] 
- The Manhattan real-estate market is finally bouncing back [NY Post] 
Recently Published Elliman Market Reports
- Elliman Report: Putnam & Dutchess Sales 1Q 2021 [Miller Samuel] 
- Elliman Report: Westchester Sales 1Q 2021 [Miller Samuel] 
- Elliman Report: Riverdale Sales 1Q 2021 [Miller Samuel] 
- Elliman Report: Northwest Queens Sales 1Q 2021 [Miller Samuel] 
- Elliman Report: Queens Sales 1Q 2021 [Miller Samuel] 
- Elliman Report: Brooklyn Sales 1Q 2021 [Miller Samuel] 
- Elliman Report: Manhattan, Brooklyn & Queens Rentals 3-2021 [Miller Samuel] 
- Elliman Report: Northern Manhattan Sales 1Q 2021 [Miller Samuel] 
- Elliman Report: Manhattan Sales 1Q 2021 [Miller Samuel] 
- Elliman Report: Colorado New Signed Contracts 3-2021 [Miller Samuel] 
Appraisal Related Reads
- Insurance Appraisal vs Bank Appraisal: What's The Difference? [Tom Horn/Birmingham Appraisal Blog] 
- An explosion of appraisal waivers. Is that good or bad? [Ryan Lundquist/Sacramento Appraisal Blog] 
- Amrock Mandatory Diversity Training [Appraisers Blogs] 
- NY Adds Fair Housing and Fair Lending Course Study Requirements to Appraiser Continuing Education [JD Supra] 
Extra Curricular Reads
- Unraveling John le Carré [Airmail] 
- The catcher who used a potato to get an out [MLB] 
- The history behind NYC's iconic Anthora coffee cups [6sqft] 
- Story of Denver's disastrous bid for 1976 Olympics [Sports Illustrated] 
- The Story of One Dose [NY Magazine] 
- Forgotten Copy of Super Mario Bros. Sets Record at Auction [NY Times]