Fast Food Visualizations On Housing
Sometimes art just jumps out of the picture and drenches you with a message:
Simone Vezzani particle rendering a portrait from the Bode-Museum using Redshift. pic.twitter.com/iV7eh0Crs6 — fourthree.boilerroom.tv (@fourthree_br) January 11, 2019 
But I digress…
Market Report Gauntlet Q4-2018 Downtown Boston
Although I was born in Boston and had traces of an accent until we moved to Delaware when I was 6 years old, and definitely annoyed my mother for adopting the New York Yankees as my favorite baseball team, I’ve always wanted to cover the Boston market in our Elliman Report series. Last year Douglas Elliman  acquired a local firm and yesterday published our research on the Downtown Boston market .
The data within the reports cover the condo and townhouse markets in the neighborhoods of Back Bay, Beacon Hil, Charlestown, Fenway, Midtown, North End, South Boston, South End, Seaport, West End & Waterfront. Its basically a luxury market moving at a blistering pace but there was a noticeable drop in condo sales in Q4-2108.
Elliman Report: Downtown Boston Sales 4Q 2018 
Here are a few basic observations:
DOWNTOWN BOSTON HIGHLIGHTS
– “Price trends and sales for the entire year finished above prior-year levels.”
– Sales for the quarter fell year over year as median sales price edged higher
– The highest fourth-quarter inventory total in five years
– Negotiability tightened from year-ago levels as marketing time expanded
– “More sales and less inventory kept the pace of the market moving quickly in the final quarter of 2018.”
– Median sales price rose year over year after three straight quarters of declines
– Year to date median sales price was unchanged year over year as annual sales slid
– Listing inventory declined year over year for the first time six quarters
And some charts!
Market Report Gauntlet Q4-2018 Greenwich, Fairfield County
For Greenwich, CT , the news was weakness but I wonder if the crazy volitility in the financial markets were the root cause of the luxury sales slowdown countywide. Since I measure luxury as the top 10%, if those units stopped trading, the top 10% is at a lower echelon rather than an actual decline in property values.
Elliman Report: Greenwich Sales 4Q 2018 
Elliman Report: Fairfield County Sales 4Q 2018 
FAIRFIELD COUNTY HIGHLIGHTS
“Shift towards smaller sized properties as countywide sales slipped.”
– Median sales price declined for the second time in three quarters
– Number of sales declined year over year for fourth straight quarter
– Listing inventory rose after ten straight year over year quarterly declines
– Luxury price trend indicators skewed lower by a sharp decline in average sales size
– Luxury listing inventory rose year over year for the fourth straight quarter
– Entry threshold to the luxury market fell to its lowest level in four years
GREENWICH SALES HIGHLIGHTS
Overview “Condo sales surged as single-family sales showed modest slip.”
- Single-family average sales size fell sharply, pulling down price trend indicators
- Single-family sales slipped as listing inventory saw a modest gain
- Condo sales surged as listing inventory edged higher
- Sharp drop in luxury threshold reflected the shift away from the top of the market
- Luxury listing inventory expanded with a slight tightening of negotiability
And some charts!
Market Report Gauntlet Q4-2018 South Florida
The report links will be available shortly. In addition to the research for the Elliman Reports covering South Florida, I compiled 5-year sales patterns for condo/single-family properties that sold over $1M. Their high-end is seeing sales growth:
Bloomberg TV 1-17-19: The Northeast to South Florida Housing Market Connection Explored
Just before I stepped on the set, I got to look at the file photo Bloomberg took about 15 years ago (I think I’ve aged gracefully) but I was also called out for it.
Was the last time you were on Bloomberg Markets 1995? That headshot…— Hiten Samtani (@hitsamty) January 17, 2019 
Here’s the interview along with a cameo by Sam Zell, lol!
The Big Mac index shows how strong the US Dollar is
If you are wondering why foreign investors in U.S. residential real estate are not what they used to be, look no further than the Big Mac  you were about to devour. Does anyone at The Economist or really, anywhere, see the irony of the initials for “Big Mac Index” are “BMI ” or am I over thinking this?
This Week in Aspirational Pricing
The quip “I’m like a farmer, outstanding in my field” crossed my mind when interviewed for this epic profile piece  on prolific New York developer Gary Barnett and his Extell firm.
His success opened the door for other high-end towers across the city, permanently altering the Manhattan skyline. “The frenzy around One57 gave everyone the idea that this was a market that was ripe to be harvested,” said real-estate appraiser Jonathan Miller.
Barnett is currently building the tallest condominium in the world, over 1,500 feet high. This WSJ piece “The Man Behind Billionaires’ Row Battles to Sell the World’s Tallest Condo ” supposed to be on the front page of WSJ today but it was bumped off to the real estate section. When I read this piece and their announcement of a new CEO, it made me wonder if investors were getting worried about the timing of this super luxury project in the middle of a market reset. Their nearby project One57 still has a lot of units left to sell and this new project is priced higher (however it is 50% taller with more views) and has twice the number of units. Will this project be the marker for the end of this era through “Billionaire’s Row ?”
Aside from those concerns, I’ve always found this form of innovation fascinating and the constant change to the skyline exciting. Just peruse some old Dover-type books  to see what I mean.
Foreclosures Are So Not A Part of The Housing Conversation Now
Here’s a press release from Attom (who acquired Realtytrac): U.S. Foreclosure Activity Drops to 13-Year Low in 2018 
New in the Real Estate Lexicon: Down
The housing market conversation is using the word “down” quite a bit more than in the prior several years: California Existing Homes in December: Sales Down 12% YoY, Inventory Up 31% [Calculated Risk] 
High Student Loan Debt and Low Homeownership Rates
The Federal Reserve released a research piece that includes discussion of the student loan debt crisis in a chapter called: Can Student Loan Debt Explain Low Homeownership Rates for Young Adults? 
From 2005 to 2014, homeownership among 24-32 year-olds fell 8.8%.
The part of the “school debt to housing” connection that doesn’t get discussed is just how much the credit side of student loans mirrors what happened during the housing bubble. Schools can keep raising tuition because it is not seen by the students – everything can be covered by the easily-issued debt. Why do you think tuition costs have outpaced inflation?
College marketing commonly touts how more than half of their students graduate in 6 years! (in a 4-year program). My wife and I attended orientation for one of my sons. In the presentation, honor roll students were brought on stage and both the school and students touted how many students were getting a major AND 3-4 minors. None of that makes much economic sense. By now the disconnect between the cost of a college education and the benefit to their careers is being talked about. Fast and loose credit has enabled reckless spending by universities. There are no checks and balances – simply raise the fees and the students will pay for it…for years.
Here was the authors’ previous piece on the topic: A Trillion Dollar Question: What Predicts Student Loan Delinquency Risk? 
All told, our finding that student loan balances are only a poor predictor of future student loan delinquencies challenges aspects of the popular narrative that frequently link borrowers with high student loan burdens (and often advanced degrees) to student loan debt repayment difficulties.
[Ritholz: MIB Podcast] Len Kiefer, Freddie Mac Deputy Chief Economist
My friend Barry Ritholtz interviews my zen-god for mortgage-related visualizations , Len Kiefer for his Masters in Business Radioshow/Podcast. Len is an amazing follow on twitter .
Upcoming Speaking Events
These aren’t upcoming but I had a great time speaking on the 84th floor of 1 World Trade Center this week with this view:
(For earlier appraisal industry commentary, visit my old clunky REIC  site.)
CoesterVMS is experiencing severe financial problems
If you haven’t been paid, I suspect it is a long shot for appraisers to recover anything from them. The irony here is that many AMCs attempt to verify an appraiser’s financial wherewithal when signing them up yet I suspect the shoe is more often on the other foot, especially when considering the scale of a controversial company like CoesterVMS.
Dave Towne wrote a piece on what to do if you’re still owed money by CoesterVMS .
Here’s an email I received as a certified appraiser in Connecticut. I’ve never done any work for them but it is nice to see that they are being proactive.
OFT (One Final Thought)
Only because this is weird.
There are no coincidences pic.twitter.com/9AEbbuXZGn — Elon Musk (@elonmusk) January 3, 2019 
Brilliant Idea #1
If you need something rock solid in your life (particularly on Friday afternoons) and someone forwarded this to you, or you think you already subscribed, sign up here for these weekly Housing Notes . And be sure to share with a friend or colleague if you enjoy them because:
- They’ll migrate to Florida;
- You’ll borrow to add 4 more college minors to you existing major;
- And I’ll revisit my childhood Boston accent.
Brilliant Idea #2
You’re obviously full of insights and ideas as a reader of Housing Notes. I appreciate every email I receive and it helps me craft the next week’s Housing Note.
See you next week.
Reads, Listens and Visuals I Enjoyed
- U.S. Foreclosure Activity Drops to 13-Year Low in 2018 [ATTOM Data Solutions] 
- California Existing Homes in December: Sales Down 12% YoY, Inventory Up 31% [Calculated Risk] 
- Expected Gains in Remodeling Spending to Slide Lower in 2019 – Blog [Joint Center for Housing Studies of Harvard University] 
- Can Student Loan Debt Explain Low Homeownership Rates for Young Adults? [Federal Reserve] 
- Microsoft pledges $500 million to tackle housing crisis in Seattle, Eastside [Seattle Times] 
- Major NYC Subway Line Shutdown Plans Still In Limbo [Next City] 
- Fed Says Student Debt Is Hurting U.S. Housing Market [The Wall Street Journal] 
- Why mortgage lending at Wells Fargo Chase and Citi plunged [MarketWatch] 
- Opinion | Consider Firing Your Male Broker [The New York Times] 
- Every Graph Tells a Story [Bloomberg] 
- $33.3 Trillion Housing Market Up 49% Since 2012 – A Third of the Gain From California [Zillow Research] 
- Markets Take the Lead When It Comes to Factoring in Recession [Bloomberg] 
- The History of What Was Heretofore Known as the Time Warner Center [Commercial Observer] 
- Iconic Chrysler Building Hits the Market, Could Go for $500M-Plus [Commercial Observer] 
- Crowded Cities Short on Housing Are Looking to Turn Water Into Land [Slate] 
- Len Kiefer Discusses the Housing and Mortgage Markets (Podcast) [Bloomberg] 
- Elderly Couple Killed In Fire At Luxury Manhattan High Rise [CBS New York] 
My New Content, Research and Mentions
- The Man Behind Billionaires’ Row Battles to Sell the World’s Tallest Condo [Mansion Global] 
- Westchester apartment sales trend up as house-hunters hibernate [Real Estate Weekly] 
- Single-Family Home Sales Rise in South Florida [Mansion Global] 
- Greenwich condo sales surge as buyers shift toward smaller homes [The Real Deal] 
- The Man Behind Billionaires’ Row Battles to Sell the World’s Tallest Condo [The Wall Street Journal] 
- Florida Seeing an Uptick in Demand for Million-Dollar Homes, Miller Samuel CEO Says [Bloomberg] 
- South Florida Mansion Sales Surge as Tax Exiles Seek Savings [Bloomberg] 
- Palm Beach homes: Fourth-quarter condo sales far outpace single-family deals, reports show [Palm Beach Daily News] 
- Q4 Fairfield County housing market down in single-family and luxury activity [Westfair Online] 
- Median downtown Boston townhouse price jumped at the end of 2018: Report [Curbed] 
- Boston’s Wealthiest Buyers Take a Pause [Mansion Global] 
- Downtown Boston condo market sees sharp drop in sales as median price hits $838,500 [Curbed] 
- Greenwich Home Prices and Sales Fall [Bloomberg] 
- London, New York and Hong Kong Are No Longer Immune to Global Housing Downturn [Bloomberg] 
- Is it better to rent or buy in NYC? [Curbed] 
- Upper East Side Co-ops Losing Their Luster [Habitat Magazine] 
- What’s Driving Down NYC Home Prices? [WCBS 880] 
- Queens Real Estate Reaches New Record; Brooklyn Continues To Climb [CBS New York] 
- Market holds is breath after 2018 pricing reset [Real Estate Weekly] 
- Луксозните жилища по света ще продължат да поевтиняват и… [BG News] 
- Steven Cohen Has a Penthouse Problem [Institutional Investor] 
- Why It’s Hard to Get a Home’s Exact Square Footage—And Why It May Not Matter [Mansion Global] 
- Lúc này có phải là thời điểm tốt để mua nhà? – Địa Ốc [Vien Dong Daily] 
- Why Buyers and Sellers Should Pay Attention to Rental Data in Their Area [Mansion Global] 
- Looking To Rent In Manhattan This Winter? Bundle Up Your Wallet And Expectations [Forbes] 
- Good News for Manhattan Apartment-Hunters: Rents Are Down Again [National Real Estate Investor] 
- The longest government shutdown on record could have widespread consequences for the US economy [Markets Insider] 
- Real Estate Report Shows Buyers and Renters In Driver’s Seat [New York 1] 
- 特朗普税改一年后美国楼市呈两极分化_网易海外置业 [Netease Overseas Real Estate] 
- First- and Second-Home Buyers Can Expect Discounts in 2019 [Bloomberg] 
Recently Published Elliman Market Reports
- Elliman Report: Fairfield County Sales 4Q 2018 [Miller Samuel] 
- Elliman Report: Greenwich Sales 4Q 2018 [Miller Samuel] 
- Elliman Report: Downtown Boston Sales 4Q 2018 [Miller Samuel] 
Appraisal Related Reads
- At What Point Does an Appraiser Need Geographic Competency? [Cleveland Appraisal Blog] 
- Bonding Company Info for CoesterVMS for if You Are Owed Money [Dave Towne/Appraisersblogs] 
- At least read this part of the appraisal [Sacramento Appraisal Blog] 
- Appraisal process for consumers [ConsumerHomeValue.com] 
- Will buyers step on the gas or brakes in 2019? [Sacramento Appraisal Blog] 
Extra Curricular Reads
- PODCAST: 10,000 Economists Walk Into A Bar [The Indicator from Planet Money] 
- The age of the missing airliner is coming to an end [Quartz] 
- I Tracked My Whole Life In A Google Sheet For A Year — Here’s What I Learned [Digg] 
- How Millennials Became The Burnout Generation [Buzzfeed News] 
- EFF flips Bird the bird, says Boing Boing post doesn’t violate copyright law [Ars Technica] 
- L.A. Punk Band X Announce New Vinyl Reissues [Pitchfork] 
- The Big Mac index shows currencies are very cheap against the dollar [The Economist]