The Danger of Drawing Housing Markets With Avocados
But if you are inclined to draw, make sure you are very careful with avocados or you won’t be able to. Prices are booming…
… but so are avocado-related trips to the emergency room.
Got it? Now back to drawing the market.
Elliman Report: Manhattan Brooklyn & Queens Rental Markets
Douglas Elliman published our monthly rental market research on the rental market this week. The April 2017 Elliman Report on Manhattan, Brooklyn & Queens is part of our expanding report series I’ve been authoiring since 1994. The market continued to show significant polarization by being soft at the top and strong in the entry-level. One of the easiest ways to illustrate this phenomenon is comparing doorman and non-doorman median rental prices. While there is a lot of overlap in property types, this breakout is literally a 50/50 split.
Here’s my take on it (I am making up for taking band in high school).
although Bloomberg presents a much better version with our data…
This chart made it to the prestigious “chart of the hour” on the Bloomberg Terminals
…and was the 8th most emailed (9th most read) on the Bloomberg terminals world wide.
Here are some of my favorite Manhattan rental charts we created this month.
Streeteasy Premier Agent is not leveling the playing field
The Real Deal magazine has been going after the new “Premier Agent” product that caused an uproar in the broker community because the actual listing agent was hidden from view and only those agents that paid to be on the site would have their names adjacent to the listing. In Konrad Putzier’s column this week, he explores this concept further. It was very odd to see Streeteasy stand by their position given the unethical nature. Finally they acquiesced by creating a navigation path to get to the listing agent. What I originally loved about Streeteasy before it was acquired by Zillow, was their neutral position in the market. They built a better mousetrap than the individual brokerages to display listing information and as a result, they became ubiquitous. Now they seem to recognize their lack of competitors and continue to figure out new ways to screw up the site over time.
In real estate today, there are magazines, events and cable access shows where the speakers, or moderators “pay to play” and as a result, the content sucks because the product is not the best that can be offered and the only people that view it are those that paid to play. Streeteasy seemed to ascribe to that model by hiding the listing agent.
The program results in “agents getting opportunities & consumers getting choice,” Spencer Rascoff, CEO of Streeteasy parent Zillow, tweeted last week.
whereas I contended that
“This concept of leveling the playing field is very misleading,” said Jonathan Miller, CEO of Miller Samuel. “Anytime you pay to play, there is no factoring in competence or local market knowledge. It has nothing to do with the playing field. It has everything to do with who has the most money to pay to be in front of the consumer.”
And that, my friends, screws the consumer since they don’t understand the nuances of who is listing the property. I understand Streeteasy needs to make money, but presenting content and expertise transparently to the consumer is just as important.
Why we won’t see meaningful housing related policy change soon
Politics and personal feelings aside – whatever your views are, Josh Brown, CEO of Ritholtz Wealth Management makes a compelling case as a regular on CNBC Fast Money that the Trump Trade is over. The market has already decided, based on actions, that the current administration, with all the political distractions, isn’t likely able to follow through on their promises this year.
To housing, that suggests there won’t be a big tax cut, no singificant increase in interest rates, no GSE reconfiguration this year.
The Housing Recovery That Wasn’t
For many U.S. housing market observers, the benchmark determinant of whether we got back to zero has been the S&P/Case Shiller Index. My extreme distaste for this index aside. Only recently has the index exceeded the 2006 peak – that we dug out of the hole we fell into.
Based on a compelling analysis by Trulia, we aren’t quite there yet. For example, home prices in NYC metro are largely below 2006 prices. You can see how the coastal U.S. severly lags price recovery of the central U.S.
Trulia looked at income and home value recovery in this interactive chart its extremely compelling.
The Retail Real Estate Apocalypse
Just walk down a street in the downtown section of your town and take a look at the vacant storefronts. There are probably a lot of them. There is an interesting shift that is occuring. Consumers have been drawn to new urbanism housing trends, you know, walkable cities. Yet the retail that gives them something to walk to is evaporating in front of them.
It’s being called the “Retail Apocalypse” since 90,000 jobs at brick and mortar retail have been lost since October.
Yes, Amazon has played a role, but Lois Weiss, retail journalist maven, provides another nuts and bolts view in her Bisnow column: Retail Is Being Manipulated To Live Another Day
In this Bloomberg Gadfly piece, you can see that department stores are being crushed.
Other Research of Interest
Lower Manhattan Real Estate Market Overview Q1 2017 – This is a study on the economy in lower Manhattan from the Downtown Alliance. I provide them the residential rent and sales data research from my work on the Manhattan sales and rental reports for Douglas Elliman – conditions continue to improve.
Knight Frank Prime Global Cities Index – Knight Frank is a global real estate services firm that has an alliance with Douglas Elliman. I provide housing data for this particular report in markets that I cover in our Elliman report series. Their graphic designers must be on steroids. It’s a fascinating report.
Autocrats and Skyscrapers: Modern White Elephants in Dictatorships: This a fascinating white paper on the proliferation of tall towers worldwide. I discovered this through Citylab, which does great job discussing the phenomenon and bringing in other insights from the Council on Tall Buildings and Urban Habitat.
The trend is staggering…
But the Citylab article provides the best answer in the subtitle:
Why Do Autocracies Build Taller Skyscrapers?
Short answer: Because they can!
Earlier in these Housing Notes, I talked about a Zillow/Streeteasy product called Premier Agent that caused a firestorm in the real estate brokerage community. They were ommitting the actual listing agent from properties that appeared on the site and only presented broker contacts adjacent to it that paid for placement. They eventually compromised, but I was struck by how hard they defended a practice that was clearly misleading the consumer. Being a disrupter as Zillow is, doesn’t mean they have to be unethical. Think about Napster and Uber for example. Now Zillow is in the spotlight again for their “Zestimate” product which has successfully “normalized” AVMs as something everyone can rely on even though they repeatedly say it is not an appraisal.
Zillow Gets Sued Over Zestimates
I linked out to this lawsuit in last week’s Housing Notes but it is starting to snowball. Now columnist Ken Harney writes a great piece on the lawsuit and Phil Crawford landed an interview with the plaintiff, Barbara Anderson, who also happens to be a lawyer.
Zillow’s website prominently disclaims its “Zestimates” are not appraisals, but are merely computer-generated estimates intended to help those looking to sell, buy or refinance a home gain a “ballpark” idea of what a house may be worth. She said Zillow’s estimates primarily rely on public information, but can be adjusted based on information homeowners may provide themselves, to provide key details and information, such as square footage or completed home renovations, that Zillow could not otherwise know.
My key issue with the Zestimate is how they present it. A Zestimate on a house is presented to the dollar. It infers a precsion that doesn’t exist. I’ve been saying that for a decade including in meetings with their president early on and other executives, as well as in this WSJ article back in 2007 when the Zestimate screwed up the value of my home. When I edited my home attributes to correct public record, my value at the time increased 500%. I liked that number better but I wasn’t on drugs.
The SEC is Looking at BPO Inaccuracy in Homebuilder Valuations
Here’s a short clip on whats happening from Bloomberg Radio.
Sports Aside: Derek Jeter Thanks New York
While I don’t bring sports into Housing Notes very often, there is a very good website called The Players Tribune. It’s got a lot of great stories about the trials and tribulations of professional atheletes in their own words. Derek is reportedly close to buying the Florida Marlins and I think he wanted to make sure he didn’t snub New York in the process. I watched him play for two decades. I love this guy.
A Brilliant Idea
If you need something rock solid in your life (particularly on Friday afternoons) and someone forwarded this to you, or you think you already subscribed, sign up here for these weekly Housing Notes. And be sure to share with a friend or colleague if you enjoy them. They’ll eat more avocados, you’ll sketch coffee cups and I won’t fall asleep in court.
See you next week.
Jonathan Miller, CRP, CRE
Miller Samuel Inc.
Real Estate Appraisers & Consultants
Reads, Listens and Visuals I Enjoyed
- Top-heavy tower makes space for luxury Manhattan residences
- Real Estate ‘Love Letters’ Spark Concern Over Racial Bias [Wall Street Journal]
- Trump Plaza New Rochelle Dumps Trump Org [The Real Deal]
- How Old Is This Old House? [NY Times]
- Rust Belt City’s Pitch for a Hot Housing Market: Free Homes [Wall Street Journal]
- New York City Has Once Again Defied the Doomsayers. Here's Why. [Bloomberg]
- Down Payment Percentages Are Stagnant Despite High Home Values [The Real Deal]
- The housing theory of everything [Works in Progress]
- Soaring Rents Make It a Very Good Time to Own an Apartment Building [Wall Street Journal]
- House Price to Median Income [Calculated Risk]
- The Federal Government Sells Flood-Prone Homes To Often Unsuspecting Buyers [NPR]
- In defense of the “gentrification building” [VOX]
- President Biden to Tap Mike Calhoun for FHFA Director [Inside Mortgage Finance]
- CRE Mulls Whether Federal Vaccine Rules Will Push Workers Back To Workplaces [Bisnow]
- HFZ church project foreclosure sabotaged $61M investment, suit charges [Crain's New York]
- Always Pay the Rent? It May Help Your Mortgage Application. [NY Times]
- Canadian Household Debt Is Rising Faster Than Income At A Record Rate [Better Dwelling]
- The Rapid Increase in Rents [Calculated Risk]
- Talkin’ ’bout my gentrification [City Observatory]
- What you need to know about NYC's basement apartments [6sqft]
- Most expensive home in America defaults on $165 million in debt, heads for sale [CNBC]
- Forbearance Will Not Lead to a Huge Wave of Foreclosures [Calculated Risk]
- Most of the apartments where New Yorkers drowned were illegal residences. [NY Times]
My New Content, Research and Mentions
- Inside young New Yorkers' 'wild ride' of Delta-era apartment hunting as they swarm 80-person open houses, realtors ghost, and rents skyrocket [Business Insider]
- An $8.3M Condo is Williamsburg’s Priciest Sale Ever [The Real Deal]
- New York Renters Face 70% Increases as Pandemic Discounts Expire [Bloomberg]
- Palm Beach Broker Targets Mansion Buyers With $46 Million Lot [Bloomberg]
- How Brooklyn Real Estate Is Faring After 18 Months of COVID [Commercial Observer]
- The Financial District aims for a post-pandemic rebound, according to LCOR's Anthony Tortora [New York Business Journal]
- Suffolk Closeup: Affordable housing crisis in the county [Shelter Island Reporter]
- Most Affordable Housing Markets in New York [MSN]
- NYC sees new records for lease signings but Delta causes some 'weakening' [Brick Underground]
- Lower Manhattan turned into a 24/7 community after 9/11. Midtown NYC could heed this lesson post-pandemic. [News Nation USA]
- Lower Manhattan turned into a 24/7 community after 9/11. Midtown NYC could heed this lesson post-pandemic. [Washington Dailies]
- Lower Manhattan Turned Into a 24/7 Community After 9/11. Midtown NYC Could Heed This Lesson Post-Pandemic. [NBC Washington]
- TVEyes Media Monitoring Suite - [Transcript] [TVEyes]
Appraisal Related Reads
- Freddie Mac Research Explores Causes for the Appraisal Valuation Gap for Homeowners in Minority Neighborhoods | Freddie Mac
- Price reductions don’t mean the market is crashing [Sacramento Appraisal Blog]
- Home appraisal increased by almost $100,000 after Black family hid their race [Cincinnati]
- The housing market is trying to get back to normal [Ryan Lundquist/Sacramento Appraisal Blog]
- UWM launches AMC-free appraisal program [HousingWire]
Extra Curricular Reads
- The 2021 Mets Season As Told Through 15 Steve Cohen Tweets
- NYC Food Delivery Workers Face Paltry Pay and High Risks, Analysis Shows [The City]
- Revolt of the Delivery Workers [Curbed]
- The Forgettable David Bowie Song That Changed the Music Industry Forever [Inside Hook]