Seeking Affordability For Distorted Reasons: Commuting and Appraising
I just moderated a panel discussion in Boca Raton at a real estate event and it was disorienting. It was 80 degrees and there were palm trees, bright aqua colored water with whitecaps, strong winds blowing inland across the beautiful sand and everyone seemed to be lounging by the pool eating fresh seafood. Admittedly I wasn’t that comfortable being so relaxed in this nirvana so I’m glad I’m back in Connecticut where the temperature is 30 degrees colder, the leaves are turning colors and not a coconut in sight. Apparently I thrive on cold and stress.
To re-orient myself, I wrote quite a bit in the “Appraiserville” section on the appraisal industry. Even if you are not an appraiser, the appraisal process impacts anyone in the real estate business. But before you work your way down this Housing Note, check out this cool info graphic on commuting.
Commuting Costs Gone Wild
With declining affordability in urban markets, the suburbs are booming.
Back in the mid 1990s after my wife and I moved to Fairfield County, Connecticut from Manhattan, I noticed the decline in housing prices further from the first express stop on the commuter train in Stamford, CT.
I worked on an updated version of the concept for last weekend’s New York Times Real Estate section: What’s Your Commute Time Worth? They did an amazing job on the graphic. I’m working on another idea for them to be shared here in a couple of weeks.
Moving to the Suburbs is not a trend for the Wealthy
There was a great WSJ article on the migration patterns out of metro areas: More Americans Leave Expensive Metro Areas for Affordable Ones The article spoke to me because we are seeing this EXACT pattern in a big way in NYC metro and in other large high cost urban markets. Megacommuting is expanding into a huge deal in Silicon Valley/LA.
Those mostly likely to move from expensive to inexpensive metro areas were at the lower end of the income scale, under the age of 40 and without a bachelor’s degree, the analysis by home-tracker Trulia found.
That’s why we are seeing heavy sales volume in the suburbs while the high end remains weak. This WSJ graphic says it all.
Too Many Urban Parking Spaces Are Bad for City Revivals
A parking space in Hong Kong sold for 550,000 euros (US$610,000) and that’s not uncommon in New York. Despite the high cost, it is fairly rationale when you consider the unit was a modestly priced $HK 56 million ($US7.2M) if you look at these amenities in the context of the properties they are associated with. Hong Kong has the least affordable housing in the world.
In Manhattan, there are parking space sales for $400,000 or more but they are associated with super luxury new developments. I found the average price for a garage space was $191,025 in 2016 year to date. The spaces that have been marketed for $1 million in recent years have never sold.
Parking Irony Alert: I think we are going to be seeing more of these headlines: Oakland council approves sweeping reductions to parking for new developments because walkable cities thrive when parking is reduced. However, it makes them less affordable and consumers are being priced out to the suburbs.
Most affordable neighborhood in Brooklyn, with a catch
Speaking of affordable, the New York Post presented our info in technicolor, sort of.
That sinking feeling
This should probably be a regular column of mine since I obsess with this sinking luxury condominium projects in San Francisco known as The Millennium Tower. From the perspective of an appraiser, a valuation of a condo unit there would be chock full of hypothetical assumptions that would take up more space than the appraisal itself.
San Francisco Sues Developers Over Sinking Tower [AP/Bloomberg]
Source: Curbed SF
Fannie and Freddie are vulnerable
There was a terrific article about the vulnerability of the former GSEs in the Washington Post: Is it time to start worrying about Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac again? The initial title was “Is it time to start panicking about Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac again?”
Fannie Mae showed a profit of $3.2 billion in the third quarter so what’s the problem?
In 2008, more than 90 percent of the companies’ revenue came from risky investments involving borrowed money. Today, their revenue come primarily from guarantee fees, which are reliable and stable.
The U.S. Treasury has enjoyed taking all the profits of the former GSEs for themselves and that works while interest rates are low.
Here’s the problem:
When mortgage rates rise, which they inevitably will, the decline in the value of Fannie’s and Freddie’s mortgage holdings could well exceed their operating earnings for a given quarter, creating an overall loss. Under the companies’ agreement with the Treasury, they are required to borrow money to cover the loss. That will likely trigger headlines along the lines of, “They’re Back! Fannie and Freddie Get Another Bailout.” And that will attract the attention of the markets, which will begin to focus on the companies’ lack of capital, realize that the Treasury’s support is not open-ended and possibly start a panic.
Mortgages are a fundamental underpinning of the U.S. housing market so the sooner this misunderstood issue is resolved the better.
Appraisers Are Not Good At Being Criminals, Just Like to Appraise
In the aftermath of the financial crisis, there have been many mortgage fraud schemes revealed, using appraisers as the enablers. What has been consistent in the process has been the motivation of the appraisers – to get a few more appraisals at the typical fee. The ringleader in these schemes makes off with tens of millions of dollars while the appraiser that enabled the deal got 20 more assignments at $300 a pop. Here’s the story of a trainee who flunked the appraisal licensing test (how is that possible?). Instead of studying, he decided it would be better to steal his mentor’s license and undertake a complex fraud. Jail is next.
Speaking of AppraisalPort…
As I returned from Washington DC on Amtrak, after attending the Appraisal Standards Board Public Meeting, Bill Rayburn, founder of FNC who just got a huge payday from their sale to CoreLogic, literally sat next to me. What are the odds? Crazy. Bill has a polarizing figure in the appraisal industry, but it was certainly interesting to connect with him again and hear what he is working on next. His firm FNC had reached out to me a decade ago to try and leverage our Manhattan co-op data into some sort of analytics but ultimately I wasn’t interested. I even interviewed Bill and the COO, Bob Dorsey in separate podcasts in 2009 and 2010 respectively.
MMJ Appraisals Wins Battle, But War is Still Pending
The formerly biggest appraisal firm in the New York City region and our main competitor was known as Mitchell, Maxwell and Jackson (MMJ). The two partners, Jeff Jackson and Steve Knobel, started out in the early 1990s with a couple of assistants and made a name for themselves. During the housing bubble they exploded in growth, at one point touting an appraisal staff as high as 100. They were the beneficiary of the mortgage broker lending system that accounted for nearly two thirds of residential mortgage lending. MMJ essentially cornered the market on mortgage broker appraisals. By dominating the market, they actually did my firm a big favor by crushing all the suburban appraisal firms that would have one token appraiser cover Manhattan. Since my firm avoided mortgage brokers as much as possible during the housing bubble, MMJ’s largess essentially removed a lot of potential competition by being so dominant. Since banks never had fewer than two firms on their appraisal panels, we were unaffected.
While our firm employed salaried appraisers performing 6-8 assignments a week, the MMJ appraisers were fee based, often working 7 days and I was told could complete as many as 45 assignments in a week. It was the housing boom after all. Aggressive in sales and growth, the sky was the limit until Lehman Brothers collapsed, marking the beginning of the credit crisis. Jeff had already been phasing out of the firm to sell property in Greenwich, CT. Steven kept the business going as volume fell sharply in the post-housing bubble appraisal world that destroyed most high volume mortgage brokers.
By 2012 MMJ began a new saga, battling the NY State Department of Licensing Services. Their licenses were revoked after a year’s worth of hearings over the use of a former fee appraiser’s digital signature. Then the revocation was undone and restated a few more times as MMJ battled through litigation up the department’s pecking order. After reading the initial 2012 decision it appeared that their legal representation was so over the top with state officials that it became personal. It was my read that this is what got the state got in trouble, eventually losing a recent decision and being forced to reimburse MMJ for $115,000 in legal fees. There is a pending lawsuit against the state from Steven at this point in the amount of $10 million.
Here are the legal documents I’ve seen during this saga. This isn’t a statement or testament about the quality of MMJ appraisals or their business practices. The courts found the state over reached on the MMJ situation. Here are the documents I have. They make a good read.
Wells Fargo $50 Million Appraisal Fee Settlement
There has been a lot of talk about Wells Fargo lately but the latest has been a recent settlement of $50 million charge because Wells saddled homeowners who defaulted on their mortgages an additional fee for the appraisal without their knowledge. Here’s the part that confused me about these appraisals:
Wells Fargo typically charged $95 to $125 for the type of expedited appraisal at issue, when the actual cost was $50 or less, the complaint said. The charges added hundreds or thousands of dollars to borrower’s mortgage loans over time, the lawsuit said.
An expedited appraisal fee of $95 to $125? What are their normal turn time appraisal fees? $50? These “appraisals” had to be broker price opinions, no? Please tell me these were not standard appraisals.
Freddie Mac will waive appraisals in certain instances, including first-purchase loans
It was refreshing to see the Appraisal Institute be proactive on this new development with their letter of concern.
Unlike the Property Inspection Waiver policies announced by Fannie Mae this week which are limited to lower- risk refinance transactions the policy change by Freddie Mac appears to be oriented to purchase-mortgage transactions or transactions with the highest risk to the agency. It has become standard practice to obtain a complete interior inspection appraisal to understand things such as property condition. Unlike a refinance transaction, where a previous appraisal is likely to be on file, loan purchases generally have less information available to the agency, which is where appraisal data provides added input to risk management.
Ryan Lundquist shared this link to a Ken Harney appraisal article on December 16, 2001.
The nation’s biggest source of home loan money quietly has been moving to minimize the cost and eliminate the required use of one of the most traditional elements of the mortgage process — the appraisal.
Here’s a followup question to Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac. How’d that decision work out? As I like to use Mark Twain’s quote (paraphrased) “History doesn’t repeat itself but sometimes it rhymes.”
A Brilliant Idea
If you need something rock solid in your life (particularly on Friday afternoons) and someone forwarded this to you, sign up here for these weekly Housing Notes. And be sure to share with a friend or colleague if you enjoy them. They’ll become your doppelgänger, you’ll get a cheaper luxury rental apartment and I’ll finally find those Swedish Fish.
See you next week.
Jonathan Miller, CRP, CRE
Miller Samuel Inc.
Real Estate Appraisers & Consultants
Reads, Listens and Visuals I Enjoyed
- Home Builders Say Federal Loan Limits Shut Out Many Buyers [WSJ]
- You’re doing Zillow wrong, and driving your agent crazy [USA Today]
- More Americans Leave Expensive Metro Areas for Affordable Ones [WSJ]
- How Many Billionaires Does It Take to Buy Manhattan? [Property Shark]
- Podcast: Airbnb, housing, transit: Kim-Mai Cutler on the Bay Area’s affordability crisis [Curbed}
- San Francisco Sues Developers Over Sinking Tower [Bloomberg]
- Wells Fargo braces for losses as prosecutors delve into possible mortgage abuses [MarketWatch]
- Surveillance: U.S. to Consider Negative Rates Within 10 Years [Bloomberg]
- Schneiderman announces $20M for land banks to combat blighted properties [Crains New York]
- Silicon Valley job boom intensifies ‘shocking’ commutes and housing crisis [Mercury News]
- Ask Andy: What is quantitative easing? [BBC News]
- Does New York need another Robert Moses? [Crains New York]
- In Greece, Property Is Debt [NY Times]
- Hong Kong parking space sells for €550,000 [Irish Times]
- 12 firms envision ways for New York to absorb 9 million residents [Crains New York]
- Why These Freelancers Ditched Cities For Rural America [Fast Company]
- The cost of silence in NYC? $8,000 a wall [Brick Underground]
- How the Brown Rat Conquered New York City (and Every Other One, Too) [NY Times]
- Home and rent price increases to slow, economists predict [LA Times]
- Who owns San Diego? [LA Times]
- Oakland council approves sweeping reductions to parking for new developments [East Bay Times]
- Is it time to start panicking about Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac again? [Washington Post]
- How Long is Too Long for a Luxury Property to Remain on the Market? [Mansion Global]
- Podcast: Why People Say the Oldest House in Manhattan is Haunted [DNAinfo]
- Judgmental Maps Offers Uncensored Insight Into America’s Greatest Cities + New Map of NYC [Untapped Cities]
- Rise in Sales of New Homes Surprises Economists [NY Times]
- Thousands of NYC Landlords Who Ignored Rent Caps Got Tax Breaks They Didn’t Qualify For [ProPublica]
- The World Is Out of Weapons [Bloomberg]
- Ask Andy: What is GDP? [BBC News]
- Posh sweet home Aston Martin unveils luxury Miami highrise [MarketWatch]
- The Other High Line Effect: How N.Y.C.’s Glitziest Park Spread Extreme Inequality [Fastco Design]
- London House Prices Forecast to Plunge as Brexit Chokes Market [Bloomberg]
- Tom Gores buys Holmby Hills spec house in $100-million deal involving multiple properties [LA Times]
- Vancouver hosts international housing summit [CBC]
- Familiar Territory: Foreclosures Return to Pre-Crisis Levels [DS News]
- Life in New York City before indoor toilets [6sqft]
My New Content, Research and Mentions
- For these wealthy New Yorkers, one apartment just isn’t enough [NY Post]
- In a Tight Spot: Parking Can Add a Six-Figure Premium to an Apartment Sale [Observer]
- Why do landlords offer concessions instead of lowering rent—and does it mess up the market? [Brick Underground]
- “Good Girls Revolt”—from the comfort of their giant 1960s apartments [Brick Underground]
- Inside the pitching war for new development projects [The Real Deal NY]
- W Downtown’s Six Penthouse Deal [Mansion Global]
- A condo boom that doesn’t add up [The Real Deal NY]
- How to buy your (soon-to-be) ex-spouse out of your apartment [Brick Underground]
- Property rounds: Neighborhoods gain amid changing trends [The Hour]
- Should you buy in Woodside or Sunnyside BEFORE the L train shutdown makes them more popular? [Brick Underground]
- This neighborhood has the cheapest rentals in Brooklyn [NY Post]
- 曼哈顿的房价高，但没有超级富豪的身家涨得快-手机财富中文网 [Fortune China]
- The ‘sweet spot’ of Wall Street’s playground is shrinking [Business Insider]
- What’s Your Commute Time Worth? [NY Times]
- Elliman Report: Los Angeles 3Q 2016 [Miller Samuel]
Appraisal Related Reads
- Appraisal Institute Is Concerned about Freddie Mac Changes to Appraisal Needs on First Mortgages [AI]
- Podcast: E128 Chucky is in the Field!!! [Voice of Appraisal]
- 6 Horror flicks that describe an appraiser’s job [Birmingham Appraisal Blog]
- Eastside couple arrested in massive home appraisal fraud [My Northwest]
- Wells Fargo settles appraisals court case [Valuation Review]
Extra Curricular Reads
- Study Finds That Athletes Perform Better When Reminded of Their Impending Death [Slashdot]
- How Statistics Solved a 175 Year Old Mystery About Alexander Hamilton [Priceonomics]
- Schools Dampen Enthusiasm for Water-Bottle Flipping Craze [WSJ]
- Apple ditches iconic startup sound on new MacBook Pro [Mashable]
- The Ramones Way: Street At Rockers’ High School Is Renamed For Band [NPR]
- Sony Filed a Copyright Claim Against the Stock Video I Licensed to Them [Petapixel]
- World’s longest escalator opens in China [Curbed]
- Wander Through the Charming Neighborhoods of Historic Shanghai [Citylab]