No Blue Light Specials in South Florida Real Estate
It’s been a busy, confusing but fully exposed week in housing.
We published 5 research pieces on the South Florida housing market (more on that later). We learned that naked and Playboy magazine were no longer one (but there is a housing angle to that, obviously) and some pretty good insights on basic math that will help us all deal with the hyperbole within the housing market.
First, we need to relax…
Loyal readers of Housing Notes have come to appreciate that reading this weekly column is a fully immersive experience. With that in mind I’ve provided a digitized in-store cassette tape Kmart soundtrack to be played while reading it. Lets call it a Blue Light Special for Housing Notes.
The 99-cents theory of pricing
There is a super cool New York Times column called “The Appraisal” which, all journalism considerations aside, is clearly the best named column in the history of journalism. It’s a bonus that the topics and writing is top notch.
The article “This Apartment Is Not $1 Million. It’s Only $999,000.” was inspired by two of the Manhattan housing reports released a few weeks ago that had a median sales price just shy of $1 million. Our Douglas Elliman report had a median sales price of $998,000 and Corcoran had a median sales price of $999,000. When Matt called me and we got to speaking about it, I shared a scatter chart I created for my chart column on Curbed a few years ago when describing price behavior related to the Mansion tax and how it clearly impacts consumer behavior.
[click to expand]
And with the data updated through 2015, here is the amazing chart used in the New York Times article.
Me sounding like an economist wannabe…
There is an invisible heavy hand at work, believes Jonathan J. Miller, the president of Miller Samuel, the appraisal firm that prepares Douglas Elliman’s market report. “The moral of the story is, tax policies are strong motivators to modify human behavior,” he said.
Then do the math…
My friend and prolific writer Barry Ritholtz writes a numbers tome “Don’t Be Blinded By Big, Scary Numbers” that is a must read for anyone that follows the housing market. So much of the numbers we see presented are wildly out of context all because we are being fed the numerator and not the denominator.
Median sales price has become the semi-official price metric over the years because it removes the extreme highs and lows and sees less skew than averages. I present both and more in my housing research because their relationships tell the story as well. No metric is good on its own. Here’s a quick Business Insider piece the difference between averages and medians (don’t worry, no one will know you had to brush up on them).
A hedge against inflation or insanity?
The first sale of a Manhattan apartment for more than $1 million is believed to have occurred in 1978. It was a 15-room apartment at 834 Fifth Avenue…
I don’t know the specifics of the 1978 sale but the current Manhattan co-op price record is held by a sale in that same building. Apartment 11/21A closed in December 2014 for $77,500,000.
That $1 million sale in 1978, if grown for inflation, would be $3,650,000.
Housing credit (mortgage lending) still remains tight
I’ve been beating the drum since 2008 about tight credit conditions and the havoc it has played in housing patterns. Here is one of the best visuals of this phenomenon I’ve ever seen.
Keeping your city weird – new urbanism version
Portland, Oregon and Austin, Texas (do I really need to include the states?) have been good at it keeping it weird. To keep it “weird”, the idea is to keep change constant and that will actually help a city maintain its character.
When we first moved to Manhattan in 1985 from a three year stay in Chicago, we soon moved to the Upper West Side and I found an amazing place to hang out: Tower Records. In between appraisal assignments and on days off, I’d roam the aisles of Tower Records on the Upper West Side and downtown. It was a cool place but I didn’t fully appreciate why it was so special. A new documentary is out on the rise and fall of the Tower Records – here is the trailer All things must pass that explains why.
But constant change as through diversification can be difficult for current residents. A few years ago I coined (if you want to call it that) “Queens is the new Brooklyn” as a way to describe home buyers being priced out of Brooklyn’s rapidly rising real estate market. Recently I started saying that “The Bronx is the new Queens” only because prices are now rising in Queens to a point that is beginning to push new development to the Bronx. Here’s a good photo essay on current Bronx residents.
Another one of my favorite reads this week (and speaking of “naked”) and is required reading for all of my loyal readers who are New York residents. And if you are not a resident, read it anyway since it applies to everyone. It’s terrific piece by Adam Gopnik called “Naked Cities – The death and life of urban America.” The opening paragraph is incredible:
Cities can’t win. When they do well, people resent them as citadels of inequality; when they do badly, they are cesspools of hopelessness. In the seventies and eighties, the seemingly permanent urban crisis became the verdict that American civilization had passed on itself. Forty years later, cities mostly thrive, crime has been in vertiginous decline, the young cluster together in old neighborhoods, drinking more espresso per capita in Seattle than in Naples, while in San Francisco the demand for inner-city housing is so keen that one-bedroom apartments become scenes of civic conflict—and so big cities turn into hateful centers of self-absorbed privilege. We oscillate between “Taxi Driver” and “The Bonfire of the Vanities” without arriving at a stable picture of something in between.
Geeks rule but appraisers don’t
Speaking of weird, I’ve long been called a “geek (or nerd)” but of course I always correct them by saying “no, I’m a cool geek” and I own it. Of course the person that first said that to me as an attempted, but failed, dig lost their appraisal license and went out of business. Never mess with a geek as Stephen Colbert has proved.
South Florida real estate recap
The Real Deal provides a good overview of the South Florida market. Here’s the super luxury take – a $60 million sales price in Miami. My friend Senada Adzem of Douglas Elliman provides a clear description of the super luxury market and it’s linkage to Manhattan real estate.
Here are the 3Q 2015 reports just published that I author on 5 South Florida housing markets for Douglas Elliman Real Estate. I’ve been writing this expanding housing market series for more than 21 years (cough).
Overall Miami Beach housing prices were mixed as sales fell short of year ago levels and inventory expanded. Median sales price was $403,500, down a nominal 0.4% from a year ago. Average sales price increased 5.4% to $919,284 over the same period. Within the condo market, all price indicators moved higher while the single family market reflected mixed results. Overall sales slipped 11.1% to 940 from the year ago quarter as both property types fell short of year ago levels…
Median sales price for Miami’s coastal mainland surged as sales slipped due to the sharp decline in distressed sales. Condo median sales price increased 2.2% to $217,400 and single family median sales price rose 10% to $302,500 respectively from the same quarter a year ago. The luxury market, defined as the top percent of all sales in the quarter, showed weaker price trends…
Overall median sales prices for the Boca Raton housing market moved higher as available supply declined. The median sales price for a condo surged 15.5% to $179,000 from the same period a year ago. Average sales price and average price per square foot slipped nominally over the same period as all price trend indicators for the single family market moved higher than the year ago result…
Price trend indicators across single family and condo markets remained mixed as sales expanded. Condo median sales price slipped 2.4% to $278,250 while condo average sales price increased 10.1% to $410,102 respectively from the year ago quarter. The single family market reflected a similar mixed message with a 4.8% rise in median sales price to $293,000 and a 6% decline in average sales price to $458,912 respectively…
Overall Palm Beach sales activity and inventory slipped from year ago levels. There were 77 total sales in the third quarter, 1.3% below the year ago level, of which condo sales expanded 7.8% and single family sales fell 18.5%. Overall listing inventory declined 11.7% to 339 of which condo listings fell 18.6% and single family listings increased 9.6%. The net result was a faster moving condo market and a slower moving single family market…
That’s it for now. If I was anymore transparent, I’d be arrested for public nudity.
See you next week.
Jonathan Miller, CRP, CRE
Real Estate Appraisers & Consultants
- Naked Cities – The death and life of urban America. [The New Yorker]
- Bracing for Gentrification in the South Bronx [NY Times]
- Tower Records Documentary — ALL THINGS MUST PASS [Vimeo]
- Means vs medians [Business Insider]
- Real estate appraisers may be endangered [Lehigh Valley Business]
- Million-Dollar Apartments Becoming Commonplace [NYTimes 1986]
- How To Keep Your City Weird [CityLab]
- High-Cost Cities with Inclusionary Housing Policies [Urban Land Institute/YouTube]
- Don’t Be Blinded By Big, Scary Numbers [Bloomberg View]
- Volkswagen and the Future of Honesty by Peter Singer [Project Syndicate]
- Stephen Colbert and the triumph of the nerd [Washington Post]
- Luxury London Home Prices Seen Rising 21.5% in Next Five Years [Bloomberg]
- China now has more billionaires than U.S. [CNN/Money]
- Nudity and real estate [1000watt]
- $100M for-sale-by-owner penthouse exits market [NY Post]
- How much does Airbnb impact rents in NYC? [The Real Deal NY]
- Housing Credit Availability Index [Urban Institute]
- Brooklyn Real Estate to Manhattan: What’s Good? [NYMag]
- Topping Out: Industry Insiders See Price Pressure at the Market’s High End [Observer]
- NYC’s Luxury-Condo King Shifts Gears in Bid for Chinese Buyers [Bloomberg]
New Content and Research
- Miami-Dade housing market is settling in: report [The Real Deal Miami]
- This Apartment Is Not $1 Million. It’s Only $999,000. [NY Times]
- Elliman Report: Boca Raton Sales 3Q 2015 [Miller Samuel]
- Elliman Report: Fort Lauderdale Sales 3Q 2015 [Miller Samuel]
- Elliman Report: Palm Beach Sales 3Q 2015 [Miller Samuel]
- Elliman Report: Miami Beach Barrier Islands Sales 3Q 2015 [Miller Samuel]
- Elliman Report: Miami Coastal Mainland Sales 3Q 2015 [Miller Samuel]