Chicken or Steak, Housing Markets Vary in Toughness
The wedding gauntlet I mentioned a while back in these Housing Notes has come to an end until about a year from now. My wife and I attended 4 weddings in 3 months (3 in the midwest and 1 in our backyard). And if it couldn’t get any better, a nice touch was used in last wedding reception – they placed my nickname on the back of the name card. Little did I know that so many relatives and friends had the same nickname as I. “Chicken” is an odd one though.
Wall Street obsessed about Greenwich CT home prices again
Seven market reports I author for Douglas Elliman were published yesterday. I’ve been independently preparing a growing series of market reports for them over the past 22 years (and appraising in between). Two of the reports covered markets in Connecticut.
For those readers who aren’t from the NYC metro area, Greenwich, CT is a suburban town known for both its mansions and residents with strong ties to Wall Street. It’s a beautiful area close to the commuter trains.
Over the past 5 years, Greenwich did not see the run up in prices that the remainder of the region generally enjoyed. In fact, it is becoming a microcosm of the new urbanism movement. Home sales closer to the downtown are generally thriving and larger homes further away are not. Titans of industry have been known to prefer the large estates further out and when they go to sell, they price them as if the market had been booming all along. And yet those homes are the optics through which most view the state of the Greenwich housing market. This is much like the way Manhattan is seen through the lens of super luxury $100 million apartments that have slowed down when the balance of the market remains strong.
The article was the #1 most read story on the Bloomberg Terminals world wide and you can see the broader report coverage here.
Here are a few of the matrix tables in the 3Q16 Greenwich report :
Our report on Fairfield County, CT (where Greenwich is located), reflected the suburban boom developing in a number of cities that have been challenged by housing affordability. The third quarter sales totals were the second highest third quarter in a decade but high end housing markets like Greenwich and other communities like it have been lagging the county wide housing market. “Soft at the top” is an accurate way to depict most housing markets in the region.
South Florida Showed It Was Like New York City
Five of our market reports that cover the south Florida housing market were published by Douglas Elliman. I found the “soft at the top” theme was clearly evident there.
Elliman Report: Miami Beach + Barrier Islands Sales 3Q 2016
Elliman Report: Miami Coastal Mainland Sales 3Q 2016
Elliman Report: Boca Raton Sales 3Q 2016
Elliman Report: Fort Lauderdale Sales 3Q 2016
Elliman Report: Palm Beach Sales 3Q 2016
Chart of the Week: Pent-up Housing Demand via Millennials
There is nothing like a good chart and the best one was over on my fried Barry Ritholtz’s blog The Big Picture. The economist who create this and others over at Deutsche Bank, Torsten Slok, is one of the best to cover housing.
China Housing Bubble Redux
In the on again, off again Chinese housing bubble discussion (reminds of the on again, off again Canadian housing bubble discussion), Chinese home prices rose 61% YoY. I am fairly certain that Chinese wages didn’t rise 61% over the past year. Still, it’s a frenzy.
So it makes sense that Chinese investors are working hard to explore other U.S. real estate opportunities besides the three go-to’s of LA, SF and NYC. Over the past few years Chinese investors have been looking to South Florida for opportunities.
Ironically since I am attending the ASB public meeting Friday morning in Washington, I have less time to write about appraising. I’ll double down next week.
In the meantime, read this article:
AppraisersBlogs: Tell Them to Find Some Other Lesser Experienced Appraiser
And listen to this 2 part podcast from Voice of Appraisal:
Voice of Appraisal E125 A Brave New World Part 1 / The Rise of an Appraiser Czar???
Voice Of Appraisal E126 A Brave New World Part 2 / The Value Manipulating CU?!?
A Brilliant Idea
If you need something rock solid in your life (particularly on Friday afternoons) and someone forwarded this to you, sign up here for these weekly Housing Notes. And be sure to share with a friend or colleague if you enjoy them. They’ll wave to big ships, you’ll shread your car and I’ll figure out why the shape of sticks of butter vary by region.
See you next week.
Jonathan Miller, CRP, CRE
Miller Samuel Inc.
Real Estate Appraisers & Consultants
Reads, Listens and Visuals I Enjoyed
- Demographics & Housing [The Big Picture]
- Climate Change Means Moving. Just Don’t Say ‘Retreat.’ [Bloomberg]
- Podcast: Half a House [99% Invisible]
- Why de Blasio’s affordable housing plan is in trouble (in 5 steps) [Crains New York]
- China Home Sales Value Rose 61% in September From Year Earlier [Bloomberg]
- Chinese share of South Florida real estate market to grow, experts say [The Real Deal SoFL]
- When Landlords Need to Keep Luxury Unit Rents High They Build a Wall [DNAinfo]
- In obsessing about New York and San Francisco, we’re ignoring the real rental crisis [Washington Post]
- FEMA’s new flood maps will save NYC homeowners from a deluge of insurance costs [Crains New York]
- New York’s Secret Doors and Hidden Rooms [NY Times]
- China Property Boom Spurs Fear of Bubble’s Burst [NY Times]
- How a power trip could doom the agency that took down Wells Fargo [Guardian]
- Rising interest rates may slow but not shock city’s economy [Crains New York]
My New Content, Research and Mentions
- Greenwich Home Prices Decline in Buyer Shift From Mansions [Bloomberg]
- Elliman Report: Miami Coastal Mainland Sales 3Q 2016 [Miller Samuel]
- Elliman Report: Miami Beach + Barrier Islands Sales 3Q 2016 [Miller Samuel]
- Elliman Report: Palm Beach Sales 3Q 2016 [Miller Samuel]
- Elliman Report: Boca Raton Sales 3Q 2016 [Miller Samuel]
- Elliman Report: Fort Lauderdale Sales 3Q 2016 [Miller Samuel]
- Elliman Report: Fairfield County Sales 3Q 2016 [Miller Samuel]
- Elliman Report: Greenwich Sales 3Q 2016 [Miller Samuel]
- When to Subtract a Home Addition [WSJ]
- Miami mainland, beaches suffer deep sales cuts in third quarter: Elliman reports [The Real Deal SoFl]
- Miami luxury condo prices take a plunge [CNBC]
- Miami Beach Market Resetting to a More Sustainable Pattern [Fang Block]
- Rents Are Down in Manhattan. You Still Can’t Afford to Live There [Bloomberg]
- Is the Market for New York Apartments Softening? [NY Times]
- America’s hunger for luxury housing may finally be satiated [The Week]
Appraisal Related Reads
- Podcast: E126 A Brave New World Part 2 / The Value Manipulating CU?!? [Voice Of Appraisal]
- What is an easement and how does it affect my property value? [Birmingham Appraisal Blog]
- How I appraised a property with a non-permitted garage conversion [Sacramento Appraisal Blog]
- Tell Them to Find Some Other Lesser Experienced Appraiser [AppraisersBlogs]
- Stigma or Superstition? [Realtor Magazine]
- Podcast: E125 A Brave New World Part 1 / The Rise of an Appraiser Czar??? [Voice of Appraisal]
- Appraisers Shortage? A Personal Story [AppraisersBlogs]
Extra Curricular Reads
- Actor Harry Shearer sues Vivendi for $125 million over ‘Spinal Tap’ profits [Reuters]
- A Look At 1980s NYC Through The Lens Of A Teenager [Gothamist]
- The Making of The Last Waltz, the Band’s Concert-Film Masterpiece [Vanity Fair]